Limits for Compact Representation of Plans

Vol. 21 (2011): Twenty-First International Conference on Automated Planning and Scheduling

Volume

Vol. 21 (2011): Twenty-First International Conference on Automated Planning and Scheduling

Full Technical Papers

Most planning formalisms allow instances with shortest plans of exponential length. While such instances are problematic, they are usually unavoidable and can occur in practice. There are several known cases of restricted planning problems where plans can be exponential but always have a compact (ie. polynomial) representation, often using recursive macros. Such compact representations are important since exponential plans are difficult both to use and to understand. We show that these results do not extend to the general case, by proving a number of bounds for compact representations of plans under various criteria, like efficient sequential or random access of actions. Further, we show that it is unlikely to get around this by reformulating planning into some other problem. The results are discussed in the context of abstraction, macros and plan explanation.

10.1609/icaps.v21i1.13446